Our German Recipe Cookbook

Another great      Kitchen Project  

First Name:
Primary Email:

we keep your email and name private

More German Recipes 
Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie

This is a different sort of Chicken Pot Pie than what you pick up in the supermarket frozen section. Instead of the pastry crust it has big squares of noodles. This is a Pennsylvania Dutch Classic.

Ingredients:                                 Serves 4
1 Large Frying Chicken
3 Quarts water
Onion flakes or one large onion
10 peppercorns
4 cloves garlic
Bay Leaf
2 cloves

2 cups carrots chopped in 1 inch chunks
2 cups onions chopped 1 inch dice
2 cups celery chopped 1 inch pieces
4 cups loosely packed potato in 2 inch chunks
(about 4 medium potatoes, I used peeled russets)
a pinch of saffron (or soaked annato seeds for color)

5 large eggs
5 half egg shells of water or 1/2 cup
about 2 to 3 cups flour to thicken. extra if needed
1 teaspoon salt

tomato powder , spinach powder to color noodles

printer friendly           Metric Conversion Chart


Find Dutch ovens , Saffron, Tomato and Spinach powder

Cooking the Chicken

I am always looking for a good excuse to use the nice Dutch oven
my folks gave to me,

1. This can be done a day ahead. Simmer the chicken in the Dutch oven with 3 to 4 quarts of water, the onion, bay leaf , peppercorns, garlic and cloves for 45 minutes until tender. On a note, I added some seasoning salt to pat the chicken with before I added the stock, I didn't put this in the ingredients because it is not traditional. I then browned the chicken just slightly to give the stock more color.

Strain and reserve the stock.
Pull the chicken off the bones and reserve to a bowl.

Here we have the Chicken, the chopped vegetables, potatoes ready to go and the noodles. George Moser sent me these nice colored noodles so I used those. See below how to make your noodles first.
The potatoes are chopped larger than the carrots so they will take approximately the same time to cook. It is ok for the potatoes to break down a bit as that helps thicken the stock.

The Noodles

1. Break the eggs into the bowl

2. Add the water and salt. This was my grandma's trick to fill the half egg shell with water. so her rule of thumb was to add a half egg shell of water per egg.

Add the flour a half cup at a time and mix it in.

If you are going to add your tomato or spinach powder you can add 1/2 cup of the powder.

Keep adding a little at a time until the dough starts to get stiff and pull away from the bowl.

Now put out on the board and add a little extra flour and work it in till it is stiff enough to roll out.

Roll out dough to a sheet about 1/4 inch thick. This is easiest to do when the dough is room temperature.

Cut the noodles into squares or strips. these are about 2 inches by 4 inches. Sprinkle some flour over these noodles until ready to use. You can also lay them on sheets and dry them.


Putting Together the Pot Pie

Bring the stock to a simmer and add the carrots, onions, celery and potatoes.

Drizzle in a tablespoon or 2 of annato oil that you get from soaking the seeds in oil. The Penn Dutch like Saffron but I didn't have any. This is mainly for coloring the broth a nice yellow. The Saffron however adds a nice flavor.

Cover and simmer the stew for 30 to 45 minutes.

Take a potato and carrot out and check for tenderness.

When they are starting to get tender add the noodles. a little of the flour that clings to the noodles is fine. Stir the noodles as they fall in so they don't stick together. After they have been exposed to the heat for a 15 seconds they will be fine.

Now simmer for another 15 minutes until noodles are done and the stock has thickened.


Here is how it looks completed. You can thicken the stock more if you like by using a slurry of
2 tablespoons flour and 1/ 2 cup water, and pour in while stirring gently with a spoon, as it is simmering.

Chop a small handful of parsley. Add half of it to the Pot Pie and gently stir in.

Top the Pot Pie with some of the chopped parsley for garnish.


Warm your bowls in the oven and Ladel some of the Pot Pie filling in the bowl distributing the vegetables and noodles evenly. Then ladle some of the sauce over the top. I like the sauce not too thick, about the same as cream.


Fried Pot Pie

This makes an excellent breakfast and any meal for that matter.

Scoop out 1 cup or so of the chilled Pot Pie.

Bread it in some seasoned flour

Fry in some oil or oil and butter. They are delicious!

More Links and Recipes

Lodge Logic 4-Quart Cast-Iron Camp Dutch Oven

Lodge Logic Dutch Oven with Loop Handles


Annato Seeds

Annatto Seed - 4 OZ  


Frontier Naturals Saffron -- 1 g  

Tomato Powder

Tomato Powder, 2 oz.  

Spinach Powder


Spinach Powder, 2 oz.  

Geschnetzelt Chicken

Brewmeister's Chicken



Our Family

from a
German Grandma

Browse Through Our Book Here

Comes with 28 Bonus Step by Step Recipes with color pictures.

See the whole list of Bonus Recipes with step by step pictures



Looking for another recipe?

Enter your recipe request and search


Where to shop for German Foods and Things

I order from the German Deli more frequently than ever.
I try to get in bulk to make the shipping dollars count.
Also there are sales all the time I like to take advantage of.
They are nice folks. If you don't believe me call them.
and tell them Stephen Block sent you from the German Goodies Newsletter
Shop for German Food

Go here and search for all kinds of German Food

Shop for German Clothing,
Cooking equipment for German Food,
Fun German stuff

more information

Come in and Shop!

From the German Plaza

Do you have a question or comment on this recipe?
make sure you put the recipe name in the subject line

Listen to German Music
Listen to the Chicken Dance, and download it
CD's recommendations and links

Do you have a German Name?
Also what your German name means

Do you want to learn to speak a little German?
Learn one word a day.

Explore your German Heritage
Find out if your relatives came over through Ellis Island and more good links





Back to top

E-Mail The Webmaster stephen@kitchenproject.com
© 1998- to present The Kitchen Project 

Last updated March 14, 2012